Let’s get started
By clicking ‘Next’, I agree to the Terms of Service
and Privacy Policy
Jobs / Job page
Senior Underwriter - Seneca E&S image - Rise Careers
Job details

Senior Underwriter - Seneca E&S

Crum & Forster Company Overview

Crum & Forster (C&F), with a proud history dating to 1822, provides specialty and standard commercial lines insurance products through our admitted and surplus lines insurance companies. C&F enjoys a financial strength rating of "A" (Excellent) by AM Best and is proud of our superior customer service platform. Our claims and risk engineering services are recognized as among the best in the industry.

Our most valuable asset is our people: more than 2000 employees in locations throughout the United States. The company is increasingly winning recognition as a great place to work, earning several workplace and wellness awards, including the 2024 Great Place to Work® Award for our employee-first focus and our steadfast commitment to diversity, equity and Inclusion.

C&F is part of Fairfax Financial Holdings, a global, billion dollar organization.  For more information about Crum & Forster, please visit our website: www.cfins.com.

Job Description

Senior Underwriter – Seneca (New York, NY, Jersey City NJ, Morristown, NJ, or Uniondale NY hybrid)

Summary:Performs risk selection and pricing on new business, renewals and endorsements, reviews quotes prior to issuance and makes marketing calls to agents. This position requires a great deal of underwriting acumen and relationship management skills. Manages agency relationships through continued customer service and marketing activities. Responsibilities:• Lines of business underwritten include: primary property, general liability, umbrella and other lines on occasion.• Meet profitability, retention and written premium goals determined by the branch.• Make independent decisions within underwriting letter of authority and maintain proper file documentation.• Manage assigned agents efficiently including: o Regular production visitso Quarterly review of assigned brokers’ profitabilityo Identification to Profit Center Manager of potential broker conflicts & successeso Focus on service and being responsiveo Work jointly with other profit centers within the organization as needed to promote cross selling and enterprise awareness.• Assist in developing annual business goals for assigned agents/producers. Responsible for analyzing results and maintaining accountability of agency partners within the branch.• Has an in-depth knowledge of branch’s products and services.• Can clearly articulate Seneca’s value proposition and underwriting appetite.• Participate in training and initiatives to develop knowledge base.• May participate in projects.• Travel – up to 20%.• Other duties as assigned. Requirements:• Bachelor’s degree and 5+ years of P&C underwriting experience.• Possesses strong communication and analytical skills to pursue new business, appoint new agents and manager overall relationships.• Proficient in software needed to succeed.• Excellent organizational and time management skills.• Possesses, or is pursuing, underwriting and industry designations applicable to area of specialization.• Will abide by branch policies and procedures, including authority levels, to comply with Seneca’s risk control procedures.• In depth knowledge of commercial insurance products.• 3 days in either NYC, JC, or Uniondale office

What C&F will bring to you

At C&F you will BELONG

 

We value inclusivity and diversity. We are committed to equal employment opportunity and welcome everyone regardless of race, color, ancestry, religion, sex, national origin, sexual orientation, age, citizenship, marital status, disability, gender identity, or Veteran status. If you require special accommodation, please let us know.

 

For California Residents Only:  Information collected and processed as part of your career profile and any job applications you choose to submit are subject to our privacy notices and policies, visit https://www.cfins.com/onlineprivacypolicy/ca/noticeatcollection/ for more information.

 

 

Crum & Forster is committed to ensuring a workplace free from discriminatory pay disparities and complying with applicable pay equity laws.  Salary ranges are available for all positions at this location, taking into account roles with a comparable level of responsibility and impact in the relevant labor market and these salary ranges are regularly reviewed and adjusted in accordance with prevailing market conditions. The annualized base pay for the advertised position, located in the specified area, ranges from a minimum of $84,500 to a maximum of $123,900. The actual compensation is determined by various factors, including but not limited to the market pay for the jobs at each level, the responsibilities and skills required for each job, and the employee’s contribution (performance) in that role. To be considered within market range, a salary is at or above the minimum of the range. You may also have the opportunity to participate in discretionary equity (stock) based compensation and/or performance-based variable pay programs.

 

  • Flexible work arrangements.
  • Competitive compensation package.  
  • Generous 401K employer match.
  • Employee Stock Purchase plan with employer matching.
  • Generous Paid Time Off.
  • Excellent benefits that go beyond health, dental & vision. Our Wellness programs focus on your family’s complete wellness, including your physical and mental wellbeing
  • A core C&F principle is that you manage your career. To support your development, we have a wealth of ways for you to keep learning, including tuition reimbursement, industry related certifications and professional training available to you.
  • A dynamic, ambitious, fun and exciting work environment.
  • A spirit of social responsibility, matching donation program, volunteer opportunities, and an employee driven corporate giving.

 

#LI-JA1

 

Crum & Forster Glassdoor Company Review
4.2 Glassdoor star iconGlassdoor star iconGlassdoor star iconGlassdoor star icon Glassdoor star icon
Crum & Forster DE&I Review
No rating Glassdoor star iconGlassdoor star iconGlassdoor star iconGlassdoor star iconGlassdoor star icon
CEO of Crum & Forster
Crum & Forster CEO photo
Marc J. Adee
Approve of CEO

Average salary estimate

$104200 / YEARLY (est.)
min
max
$84500K
$123900K

If an employer mentions a salary or salary range on their job, we display it as an "Employer Estimate". If a job has no salary data, Rise displays an estimate if available.

What You Should Know About Senior Underwriter - Seneca E&S, Crum & Forster

Are you ready to take your underwriting career to the next level? At Crum & Forster, we're looking for a Senior Underwriter to join our Seneca team in Jersey City! With a legacy dating back to 1822, Crum & Forster has built a reputation as a leading provider of specialty and commercial lines insurance products. As a Senior Underwriter, you'll play a critical role in risk selection and pricing for new business, renewals, and endorsements. Your responsibilities will include managing agency relationships and conducting marketing calls to agents, all while meeting profitability and retention goals. You'll need a blend of solid underwriting knowledge and exceptional relationship-building skills to thrive in this role. This position allows for flexible work arrangements, with three days per week in either NYC, Jersey City, or Uniondale offices, and may involve travel up to 20%. If you have a Bachelor’s degree and over five years of P&C underwriting experience, we want to hear from you! Join us in a workplace known for its outstanding employee culture, where inclusivity and professional growth are at the forefront. Discover your potential at Crum & Forster and help us shape the future of insurance!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Senior Underwriter - Seneca E&S Role at Crum & Forster
What are the main responsibilities of a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster?

As a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster, your main responsibilities include performing risk selection and pricing for new business, renewals, and endorsements. You'll also manage agency relationships, conduct marketing calls, and ensure the agency partners meet profitability, retention, and written premium goals. This role requires strong analytical and communication skills to effectively engage with agents and brokers.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What qualifications are required to become a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster?

To qualify as a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster, candidates need a Bachelor’s degree alongside at least five years of P&C underwriting experience. Additionally, strong communication, analytical skills, and proficiency in relevant software tools are essential. Experience with commercial insurance products and pursuing further industry designations will be beneficial.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What does the work environment look like for Senior Underwriters at Crum & Forster?

Crum & Forster offers a dynamic and supportive work environment for Senior Underwriters. Employees enjoy flexible work arrangements, competitive compensation, and a focus on work-life balance. The company emphasizes inclusivity, professional development opportunities, and a culture of collaboration, making it a great place to manage your career.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How does Crum & Forster support career advancement for Senior Underwriters?

Crum & Forster is committed to employee career advancement by providing various resources for continuous learning. This includes tuition reimbursement, access to industry-related certifications, and professional training programs. The company encourages Senior Underwriters to take charge of their career development, fostering growth and skill enhancement.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What is the salary range for a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster in Jersey City?

The salary range for a Senior Underwriter at Crum & Forster in Jersey City is between $84,500 and $123,900 annually. This is determined by several factors, including market conditions, job responsibilities, and individual performance. Additionally, there may be opportunities for equity compensation and performance-based incentives.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Common Interview Questions for Senior Underwriter - Seneca E&S
Can you describe your experience with P&C underwriting?

Absolutely! When answering this question, summarize your background in property and casualty underwriting, highlighting specific roles and responsibilities you've held. Discuss any notable projects or accomplishments that illustrate your expertise, ensuring you align your experiences with Crum & Forster's underwriting standards.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you approach risk assessment in underwriting?

In your response, explain your systematic approach to risk assessment, detailing key factors you analyze—such as client history, market conditions, and data analysis. Highlight any tools or methodologies you utilize, and connect your approach to Crum & Forster's underwriting philosophy.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What strategies do you use to manage broker relationships?

Discuss your relationship-building techniques, focusing on communication, regular visits, and providing valuable support to brokers. Share specific examples of how you have maintained productive relationships and the impact it had on achieving sales and retention goals.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you ensure compliance with underwriting policies?

To answer this question, emphasize your familiarity with industry regulations and Crum & Forster’s internal policies. Describe your strategies for staying updated on compliance requirements and your methods for ensuring that underwriting documentation meets necessary standards.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What do you know about Crum & Forster's culture and values?

Demonstrating knowledge about Crum & Forster’s culture, you can mention their commitment to inclusivity, employee well-being, and professional growth. Relate how these values resonate with your beliefs and how you would contribute positively to the team.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Can you give an example of a challenging underwriting case you've handled?

Share a specific story detailing a challenging case, including the hurdles faced, your analysis process, and the final outcome. Emphasize how this experience strengthened your underwriting skills and ability to make tough decisions under pressure.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What motivates you to excel in your underwriting career?

In your response, discuss your passion for the insurance industry, drive for excellence, and the satisfaction you gain from successfully assessing risks and cheering brokers and clients. This will convey your enthusiasm for the Senior Underwriter role at Crum & Forster.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you stay current with industry trends and changes?

Explain your methods for staying informed, such as attending industry conferences, participating in webinars, and reading relevant publications. Emphasize that ongoing education is vital to maintain underwriting expertise and to align with Crum & Forster’s forward-thinking approach.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What steps do you take to ensure profitability in underwriting decisions?

Discuss your experience in setting profitability criteria while underwriters assess risks. Highlight your method of analyzing historical data, market trends, and working collaboratively with agents to achieve profitability in underwriting decisions.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Why do you want to work at Crum & Forster as a Senior Underwriter?

Your answer should reflect genuine enthusiasm for the position and the company. Highlight Crum & Forster's reputation, values, and commitment to employee development as reasons that attract you. Personal anecdotes aligning with their mission will strengthen your response.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Similar Jobs
Photo of the Rise User
Aston Carter Hybrid Kansas City, Missouri, United States
Posted 2 days ago
Photo of the Rise User
Aflac Remote Georgia, United States
Posted 9 hours ago
Photo of the Rise User
Posted 8 days ago
Photo of the Rise User
Braven Remote No location specified
Posted 9 days ago
Photo of the Rise User
Posted 12 days ago
Photo of the Rise User
hims & hers Remote No location specified
Posted 7 days ago
Dental Insurance
Disability Insurance
Vision Insurance
Equity
Paid Time-Off
Medical Insurance
Mental Health Resources
Paid Holidays
Company Retreats

Create a culture of community, fairness and dedication to those we serve, including shareholders, employees, policyholders, producers, local communities and charities.

6 jobs
MATCH
VIEW MATCH
BADGES
Badge LGBTQ+ LedBadge Women LedBadge Rapid Growth
CULTURE VALUES
Social Impact Driven
FUNDING
DEPARTMENTS
SENIORITY LEVEL REQUIREMENT
TEAM SIZE
EMPLOYMENT TYPE
Full-time, hybrid
DATE POSTED
March 26, 2025

Subscribe to Rise newsletter

Risa star 🔮 Hi, I'm Risa! Your AI
Career Copilot
Want to see a list of jobs tailored to
you, just ask me below!
LATEST ACTIVITY
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Dover just viewed Finance Intern - Summer 2025 at Spectrum
F
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed Mortgage Loan Officer Assistant at Fulton Bank
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cincinnati just viewed Amazon Work from Home Data Entry Jobs – Entry Level at Amazon
Photo of the Rise User
23 people applied to Billing Specialist at Hint Health
J
Someone from OH, Westerville just viewed Oracle Database Administrator- Remote only at JASCI
Photo of the Rise User
6 people applied to Quickbooks AR and AP at Upwork
V
Someone from OH, Toledo just viewed Sports Event Coordinator at Ventures With Jen
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Dayton just viewed Research Assistant at Leidos
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cincinnati just viewed Finance & Accounting Associate at HeadQuarters
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Canton just viewed Communications Manager at Shearer's Foods
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Sandusky just viewed Supply Chain Trainee Program (SCTP) at Anheuser-Busch
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Mason just viewed HR/Recruiting Assistant at Illumination
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Strongsville just viewed Used Car Buyer - Concord Toyota at Sonic Automotive
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cincinnati just viewed Mid-level Creative (f/m/d) at Landor
P
Someone from OH, Kent just viewed Graphic Designer at ProjectGrowth
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Waverly just viewed Client Services Manager at Pepperstone
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Plain City just viewed Aesthetic Telehealth Nurse Practitioner (remote) at Moxie
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed EdTech Product/Program Manager at Planner5D
S
Someone from OH, Lorain just viewed Test Engineer- Ninja at SharkNinja