Let’s get started
By clicking ‘Next’, I agree to the Terms of Service
and Privacy Policy
Jobs / Job page
Benefits Department Supervisor image - Rise Careers
Job details

Benefits Department Supervisor

Job Description:

Benefits Department Supervisor – Grow Your Career with Old Republic Title

Are you an experienced benefits professional looking for a leadership role in a well-established company? Do you enjoy overseeing benefits programs, ensuring compliance, and providing guidance to employees? Old Republic Title is seeking a Benefits Department Supervisor to manage key health, welfare, and retirement programs while leading a team of benefits specialists.

Why You’ll Love This Role:

  • Leadership & Impact – Supervise and guide a team while playing a vital role in managing benefits for over 9,400 employees.
  • Growth & Stability – Join a company with a strong reputation and a long-standing history of excellence in the industry.
  • Strategic Influence – Contribute to benefits program development, compliance, and process improvements.
  • Collaborative Environment – Work closely with internal teams, vendors, and external consultants to ensure smooth benefits administration.

What You’ll Be Doing:

  • Supervise & Support the Benefits Team – Provide guidance to Leave Administrators and other team members.
  • Benefits Plan Expertise – Act as a resource for employees and benefit team leaders, interpreting health, welfare, and retirement plans.
  • Ensure Compliance – Oversee ERISA compliance, FMLA administration, and regulatory filings, including ACA reporting and Form 5500s.
  • Annual Enrollment & Pension Support – Coordinate open enrollment materials, assist with pension plan administration, and oversee benefits communications.
  • HRIS & Data Management – Ensure accurate system configurations, compile reports, and analyze data for strategic planning.
  • Financial Oversight – Manage benefit invoices, oversee reconciliation, and report self-funded medical and dental claims.
  • Vendor & Stakeholder Collaboration – Work with benefits brokers, providers, and internal teams to optimize benefit programs.

What We’re Looking For:

  • 8-10 years of experience in health and welfare benefits, retirement plans, and compliance.
  • 3+ years of supervisory experience leading a benefits or HR team.
  • Strong knowledge of ERISA, federal and state leave laws, and benefits regulations.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office Suite (Excel, Outlook, Teams) and experience with HRIS/payroll platforms (Workday, UKG preferred).
  • Excellent communication & leadership skills – Ability to interact with employees, executives, and vendors in a professional and collaborative manner.
  • Detail-oriented & organized – Skilled in managing multiple priorities and ensuring accuracy in compliance and reporting.

Join a Team That Values Your Expertise!

This is a fantastic opportunity for a benefits professional seeking a leadership role in a stable, growing company. If you’re ready to make an impact while advancing your career, we encourage you to apply!

#LI-MO1

The estimated pay range stated represents the typical pay range for this position or similarly employed employees or employees performing substantially similar work. Factors which may be used to determine the actual pay rate may include, but are not limited to, education, training or experience; seniority; merit and work performance; quantity or quality of production; regional differences in compensation; differences in local minimum wages, or ability and effort.

Position's Pay Range:

$90,000 to $120,000 annually.

This position is typically eligible for bonus-based incentive compensation, at the Company’s discretion.

Benefits may include:

  • Comprehensive medical, prescriptions, dental and vision plans

  • 401(k) plan with a discretionary company match

  • Shareholder Purchase and Reinvestment Plan

  • Basic life and accidental death and dismemberment insurance premium paid by the company

  • Voluntary supplemental life insurance for employees, spouses and dependent children

  • Fertility and Family Building Benefits

  • Paid Disability benefits

  • Paid time off programs

  • 11 Company paid holidays per year

  • Flexible spending account

  • Health savings account (available to High Deductible Health Plan participants only)

  • Employee Assistance Program

  • Educational Assistance Program

  • Voluntary benefits, such as Critical Illness, Hospital Indemnity, Pet Insurance and Accident Insurance

  • Title insurance policies and certain escrow services for the employee’s primary personal residence at no charge

  • Transportation benefit plan for mass transit, parking and vanpool, in several markets

Note: If you currently are employed by Old Republic Title (or one of its wholly owned affiliated companies) please get in touch with your human resources representative regarding the application process.

For California applicants, please click the following link to view our CCPA Applicant Notice

Old Republic Title is an Equal Opportunity Employer

Average salary estimate

$105000 / YEARLY (est.)
min
max
$90000K
$120000K

If an employer mentions a salary or salary range on their job, we display it as an "Employer Estimate". If a job has no salary data, Rise displays an estimate if available.

What You Should Know About Benefits Department Supervisor, Old Republic International

Are you ready to take your career to the next level? Old Republic Title is on the lookout for a dynamic Benefits Department Supervisor to join our team in Minnetonka, MN. In this pivotal role, you’ll supervise a talented team of benefits specialists and manage essential health, welfare, and retirement programs for over 9,400 employees. We believe in empowering our employees, and this is your chance to make a significant impact. You’ll provide guidance and leadership, ensuring that our benefits programs are not only compliant but also effective and employee-focused. Your expertise will be crucial as you oversee ERISA compliance, coordinate open enrollment efforts, and manage pension administration. You’ll work collaboratively with internal teams, vendors, and external consultants to streamline benefits administration, and you'll play a key role in data management and financial oversight, too. At Old Republic Title, stability and growth go hand in hand. We're a well-established company with a reputation for excellence, and we prioritize creating a collaborative work environment where everyone can thrive. If you have a strong background in benefits management, leadership experience, and a passion for helping others navigate their benefits, this could be the perfect opportunity for you to advance your career and make a difference. Join us today and be part of a team that values your expertise and dedication!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Benefits Department Supervisor Role at Old Republic International
What are the responsibilities of a Benefits Department Supervisor at Old Republic Title?

As a Benefits Department Supervisor at Old Republic Title, your primary responsibilities include overseeing health, welfare, and retirement programs, supervising a team of benefits specialists, ensuring compliance with ERISA, managing annual enrollment, and collaborating with various stakeholders to optimize benefits administration. You’ll also be involved in data management and financial oversight of benefit-related expenses.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What qualifications are required for the Benefits Department Supervisor position at Old Republic Title?

To be considered for the Benefits Department Supervisor role at Old Republic Title, candidates should possess 8-10 years of experience in health and welfare benefits and retirement plans, along with at least 3 years of supervisory experience. Strong knowledge of ERISA, federal and state leave laws, and experience with HRIS systems is essential. Excellent communication and organizational skills are vital to succeed in this role.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How does Old Republic Title ensure compliance in its benefits department?

Old Republic Title is dedicated to ensuring compliance in its benefits department by closely monitoring regulations, including ERISA and FMLA. The Benefits Department Supervisor plays a crucial role in overseeing compliance activities and ensuring all regulatory filings are completed accurately and timely. Continuous training and collaboration with legal experts are also integral to our compliance strategy.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What kind of team environment can I expect as a Benefits Department Supervisor at Old Republic Title?

At Old Republic Title, you can expect a collaborative and supportive team environment. As a Benefits Department Supervisor, you’ll have the opportunity to work closely with benefits specialists, other HR professionals, and external partners to create a positive workplace culture. Your leadership will empower your team to resolve queries and enhance the overall benefits experience for employees.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What benefits does Old Republic Title offer to its employees?

Old Republic Title offers a comprehensive benefits package to its employees, including medical, dental, and vision plans, a 401(k) plan with a company match, paid time off, flexible spending accounts, employee assistance programs, and many more. These benefits support employees in a holistic way, promoting health, financial security, and work-life balance.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Common Interview Questions for Benefits Department Supervisor
How do you approach leading a team in a benefits department?

When leading a team in a benefits department, it’s essential to establish clear communication and set expectations. I prioritize creating an open environment where team members feel comfortable sharing ideas and concerns. It’s crucial to provide ongoing support and professional development opportunities to enhance team skills and overall effectiveness.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Can you describe your experience with compliance in benefits administration?

My experience with compliance involves regularly reviewing benefits programs to ensure they meet federal and state regulations, including ERISA and FMLA requirements. I have managed regulatory filings and audits, ensuring all documentation is accurate and up-to-date. Additionally, I stay informed about changes in laws that may impact our benefits strategy.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you handle employee inquiries about their benefits?

Handling employee inquiries about benefits requires patience and clear communication. I approach inquiries by actively listening to understand their concerns, and I provide accurate, timely information about our benefits plans. If a situation requires further investigation, I ensure to follow up and provide resolutions to maintain trust and confidence.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What strategies do you use to ensure successful open enrollment?

To ensure successful open enrollment, I implement strategic communication plans that outline key dates and highlight important changes to our benefits plans. Utilizing multiple channels—like email, webinars, and informational flyers—allows me to reach all employees effectively. Additionally, providing one-on-one sessions for questions can enhance participation and understanding.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Describe a time you improved a benefit-related process.

In my previous role, I identified inefficiencies in our open enrollment process that were causing delays. I implemented a digital solution that streamlined document submissions and approvals, which not only reduced processing time but also enhanced employee satisfaction. This not only optimized our workflow but also provided a better experience for employees.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What tools do you use for HRIS and data management in benefits administration?

I have experience with various HRIS platforms, including Workday and UKG. These tools are essential for managing benefits data, generating reports, and ensuring compliance. I also utilize Excel for data analysis to ensure accuracy in our benefits offerings and to help in strategic planning.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What is your experience with pension plan administration?

My experience with pension plan administration includes coordinating with finance teams to oversee plan contributions, managing communication regarding vesting schedules, and ensuring compliance with federal regulations. I’ve also facilitated educational sessions for employees to help them understand their pension benefits effectively.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you stay updated on trends in employee benefits?

Staying updated on trends in employee benefits is vital, and I achieve this through continuous education. I regularly attend webinars, industry conferences, and utilize professional networks. I also subscribe to relevant publications to ensure I’m aware of new policies or innovative benefits options that could enhance our offerings.

Join Rise to see the full answer
How do you handle disagreements with vendors regarding benefit services?

When disagreements with vendors occur, I prioritize communication and problem-solving. I ensure to address concerns promptly and seek to understand their perspective as well. Collaboratively discussing the issue often leads to a resolution that benefits both parties while ensuring our employees receive the best possible service.

Join Rise to see the full answer
What leadership style do you adopt as a Benefits Department Supervisor?

As a Benefits Department Supervisor, I adopt a transformational leadership style. I strive to inspire my team through clear vision, supporting their professional growth, and celebrating individual achievements. I believe this fosters a positive team culture, encouraging innovation and collaboration, ultimately benefiting our employees.

Join Rise to see the full answer
Similar Jobs
Photo of the Rise User
Old Republic International Remote FL, Orlando (6545 Corporate Ctr Blvd)
Posted 11 days ago

Join Old Republic Title as an IT Project Manager, where you'll lead medium-sized projects and guide teams to success in a hybrid work environment.

Photo of the Rise User
Old Republic International Remote MN, Minnetonka (11055 Wayzata Blvd, Ste 250)
Posted 12 days ago

We are looking for a Senior Payroll Specialist to lead payroll processing while providing expert support in a hybrid work environment at Old Republic Title.

Photo of the Rise User

As the Team Manager in HR Customer Service Delivery at Smith+Nephew, you will lead a high-performing team to enhance employee experiences through quality HR service delivery.

Posted 22 hours ago

Join Remote Recruitment as a Recruitment Resourcer and help shape the careers of candidates while collaborating with our recruitment team.

Photo of the Rise User
Evolution Hybrid No location specified
Posted 7 hours ago

Evolution Raleigh is on the lookout for ambitious Tech Recruiters ready to thrive in a dynamic American job market.

Photo of the Rise User
American Express Remote New York, New York, United States
Posted 6 days ago
Inclusive & Diverse
Empathetic
Collaboration over Competition
Growth & Learning
Transparent & Candid
Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Mental Health Resources
Life insurance
Disability Insurance
Child Care stipend
Employee Resource Groups
Learning & Development

As a seasoned leader, you will drive campus talent acquisition strategies at American Express, focusing on attracting and hiring future leaders.

Be a pivotal member of Riverside Research supporting personnel strategies for the National Space Intelligence Center in Dayton.

Photo of the Rise User

As an HR Business Partner at Montclair State University, you will serve as a key advisor to campus leadership on human resources strategies and initiatives.

Photo of the Rise User
Barry-Wehmiller Hybrid Clayton, MO USA (8027 Forsyth Ste 800)
Posted 14 days ago

BW Design Group is looking for a passionate Talent Development Specialist to drive team member engagement and development initiatives.

Photo of the Rise User
American Express Remote New York, New York, United States
Posted 13 days ago
Inclusive & Diverse
Empathetic
Collaboration over Competition
Growth & Learning
Transparent & Candid
Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Mental Health Resources
Life insurance
Disability Insurance
Child Care stipend
Employee Resource Groups
Learning & Development

American Express is looking for a Talent Partnerships & Events Analyst to enhance their recruitment strategies and develop impactful partnerships.

The Company is one of America’s 50 largest shareholder-owned insurance businesses. It is primarily a commercial lines underwriter serving the insurance needs of a large number of organizations, including many of America’s leading industrial and fi...

11 jobs
MATCH
Calculating your matching score...
FUNDING
SENIORITY LEVEL REQUIREMENT
TEAM SIZE
EMPLOYMENT TYPE
Full-time, on-site
DATE POSTED
April 7, 2025

Subscribe to Rise newsletter

Risa star 🔮 Hi, I'm Risa! Your AI
Career Copilot
Want to see a list of jobs tailored to
you, just ask me below!
LATEST ACTIVITY
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cincinnati just viewed Brand Management & Partnerships Assistant at LAIKA
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Athens just viewed Senior Multimedia Artist, Design & Creative at RepRisk AG
Photo of the Rise User
7 people applied to HR Generalist at Butter Payments
H
Someone from OH, Rocky River just viewed Training Manager at Hotel Bardo Savannah
F
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed VP of Communications at Freedom Together Foundation
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed Chief Organizational Communication Officer at Providence
Photo of the Rise User
30 people applied to HR Coordinator at Alo Yoga
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cuyahoga Falls just viewed SEASONER at Shearer's Foods
Photo of the Rise User
10 people applied to Recruiting Coordinator at Mapbox
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed Bilingual Care Manager, Telephonic RN at Humana
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed Talent Business Partner at Red Bull
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Brunswick just viewed Sanitation Team Member at Shearer's Foods
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Columbus just viewed Talent Acquisition Specialist at Beghou Consulting
C
Someone from OH, Middletown just viewed Operations Analyst at Core Specialty Insurance
A
Someone from OH, Strongsville just viewed Graphic Design Intern at Anvil NorthWest
W
Someone from OH, Uhrichsville just viewed Director Operations at WVUMedicine
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Cincinnati just viewed Game Director, Scripps Sports at The E.W. Scripps Company
o
Someone from OH, Oxford just viewed Digital Media & Marketing Student Intern at osu
Photo of the Rise User
Someone from OH, Beachwood just viewed Dispensary Tech at Ayr Wellness